Main posant des post-its sur un mur


Optimizing Project Design: The Impact of Phase Gate Models on Success 


The ability to efficiently manage projects is crucial for the success of any organization. In this context, the phase gate model emerges as a strategic tool that optimizes project design. By providing an organized structure divided into distinct phases, each marked by decision points, these models offer a systematic approach to project management.

This article will explore the impact of phase gate models on project success, highlighting how they contribute to efficiency, control, and strategic decision-making. By understanding the dynamics behind these models, organizations can significantly improve project execution, minimize risks, optimize resources, and ensure that projects are implemented within the allotted time and budget and with the required quality.

What is Project Design?

Project Design is a structured and methodical process that defines a project’s steps, from conception to implementation, ensuring that each decision contributes to the project’s overall success. A phase gate model, or stage gate, is used to facilitate control and ensure the effectiveness of each phase.

Phase-Gate Model

Project Stage/Phase

A phase is a distinct step in the project lifecycle, representing a set of activities or tasks that need to be completed before moving on to the next stage. Each phase consists of crucial decisions based on the project’s key milestones.

Project Gate

The Gates serve as control points at the end of each phase. The team undergoes a rigorous assessment, considering compliance with defined criteria. This evaluation process is a critical review of the results and decisions made during the phase, and it is decided whether the team moves to the next step or if adjustments and improvements are required before proceeding.

The Stage-Gate model provides a disciplined approach to Project Design, transforming the process into a strategically planned journey, where each phase is carefully evaluated before moving on to the next stage, thus ensuring the project’s success and effectiveness.

Designing a stage-gate model is done by creating a visual map built during a multidisciplinary team workshop.

Benefits of a Robust Project Design

The conduct of a Project Design workshop centered on defining the Stage-Gate model can provide a series of significant benefits for the project’s overall success. Here are some of the key benefits:

Identification of Critical Milestones

The workshop helps the team identify the critical milestones in each phase of the project and define the critical decisions and specific tasks that constitute each phase of the model.

Early Challenges Identification

The team can anticipate and identify potential challenges and obstacles by defining the phases and review points. This allows for implementing proactive strategies for risk mitigation.

Team Commitment

The workshop promotes active participation and collaboration among project team members and key stakeholders—sharing ideas results in more comprehensive solutions.

Informed Decision Making

Each project gate is an opportunity for the team to make informed decisions, carefully consider the mandatory criteria, and compare with other processes. This contributes to solid and well-founded decision-making.

Quality Assurance and Continuous Improvement

The stage-gate model allows the team to make continuous adjustments throughout the process. If a phase does not meet the criteria at the “Gate”, the team can review and improve before moving forward. This ensures quality and the project’s continuous improvement.

Structured Progress Assessment

The Stage-Gate model offers a solid structure for assessing project progress. It facilitates the fulfillment of milestones with quality and within the defined timeframe.

Increased Likelihood of Overall Success

By following the Stage-Gate model, with insights obtained during the workshop, the likelihood of the project’s overall success is significantly higher.

Building the Workshop Team

Any project’s success largely depends on forming a competent and diverse team. The Project Design workshop is a critical stage where the team’s composition plays a fundamental role. Creating a collaborative and inclusive environment ensures that the perspectives and knowledge necessary for the project’s success are represented. Below, we identify the key stakeholders who should actively take part in this workshop:

  • Project Leader: The project leader plays a central role in defining the project’s vision, goals, and strategic direction. Their presence is crucial to align the team with the overall objectives.
  • Technical Experts: Include members with specific technical knowledge relevant to the project who will be part of its implementation (R&D, Engineering, Quality, Production, Maintenance, Marketing and Sales, etc.). These experts provide valuable insights into the proposed solutions’ technical feasibility and effective implementation.
  • Business Representatives: Members with experience in business aspects are essential to ensure that project decisions are aligned with organizational objectives and customer needs.
  • Clients (if applicable): If the project is related to a product or service for specific end-users, including representatives from this group is relevant. They will offer a practical view of customer needs and expectations.
  • Workshop Facilitator: An experienced facilitator or consultant is essential to guide discussions, assist with methodology, maintain focus on the workshop objectives, and ensure the participation of all members.

By bringing together a multidisciplinary team, a holistic approach is taken in defining the project design, considering not only technical aspects but also business requirements and, when applicable, the end customers’ expectations. This diversity of perspectives enhances discussions, promotes innovation, and establishes a solid foundation for the project’s success.

Main Steps in Project Design: Crafting a Roadmap for Success

The project’s success is directly linked to the effectiveness of its design phase. Project Design is not just the initial stage but the design of the entire journey from design to implementation. It is crucial to adopt a well-structured approach to ensure an organized and strategic approach.

Main Steps in Project Design

Step 1: Name the Project

Begin by defining the project’s identity through naming. Conduct team discussions to decide on the project’s mission. An appropriate title should capture the essence of the solution and resonate with the team’s understanding and vision. Place the name in the lower-left corner of the sheet.

Step 2: Set the End Date

Define the temporal boundaries of the project by establishing the end date. This crucial milestone serves as a beacon, guiding the team toward timely completion. Record this date prominently, placing it in the lower-right corner of the workspace.

Step 3: Define the Purpose of Decision Reviews

Engage the team in discussions to determine the purpose of the Decision Reviews (DRs) or integration points. Clearly describe when DRs are necessary to drive the project forward or ensure the solution’s quality. Decide on the occurrence of these reviews. Place information at the bottom of the map.

Step 4: List the Decision Review Points

Name and position each Decision Review on a timeline in the center of the chart. Organize these DRs sequentially from left to right in order of occurrence. Each DR should validate the sustained completion of tasks and activity events using data.

Step 5: Define Decision Review Inputs

For each DR, define the necessary data or input items. List these inputs on post-its and place them at the top of the corresponding DR. Clearly articulate the knowledge required for informed decision-making.

Step 6: Define Decision Reviews Output

For each evaluation, agree on the exit criteria, the “Go/No-Go” factors. List these criteria on post-its below each DR. Define the necessary outputs and their respective verification/validation criteria.

Step 7: Define Core Team Functions

List the main intervention areas for the core team on the left side of the workspace. Agree on the type of leadership required for each area and define the decision-making approach (e.g., consensus, voting, debate).

Step 8: List Customers and Suppliers

Identify and list the customers and suppliers for the project, above and below the core team. Broaden the definition of suppliers to include material suppliers and sources of information and knowledge.

Step 9: Align Decision Reviews

Align each DR with a designated and agreed-upon “mother area” by the team. This ensures that each review corresponds to a specific area of focus within the project.

Step 10: List Main Work Tasks

List the primary work tasks, creating a roadmap that guides the team through the complexities of the project. Define work packages for each job, ensuring they are in line with the requirements for the ensuing DR. Each work cell should be created according to the schedule and appropriate leadership, promoting efficient progress.

Step 11: Identify Tasks Participants

Visualize a multidisciplinary team extending vertically across all areas that must collaborate on each task. Eliminate inefficiencies and streamline communication channels by identifying the main participants in each mission, fostering a collaborative and synergistic environment.

Step 12: Identify Participants in Decision Reviews

Identify the areas that must participate in the Decision Reviews. Use post-its to indicate the sections playing a role in these critical evaluations. This step ensures comprehensive input and feedback from relevant stakeholders, contributing to a complete decision-making process.

Step 13: Detail Standard Work

List the standards and procedures for each task or DR. If existing procedures do not have defined standards, initiate the SDCA (Standardize, Do, Check, Act) process to establish clarity and consistency. Plan workshops or events to create the standard work for critical tasks, ensuring this process does not negatively impact the project’s schedule.

Conclusion: Implementing a Successful Project Design

The strategic implementation of Phase gate models is an essential catalyst for optimizing project design, providing a structured approach. By integrating phases, review gates, and an iterative continuous improvement process, these models ensure effectiveness at each stage and become a reliable guide for project success. Project design is broken down into a sequence of phases and a strategically planned path, where each decision and adjustment is carefully evaluated, resulting in more efficient, controlled, and successful projects.

Still have questions about Project Design?

What is the Stage-Gate Model?

A Stage-Gate model, or a Phase-Gate, is a project management framework that divides a project into distinct stages or phases, each separated by gates or checkpoints. At each gate, a decision is made to continue to the next stage, modify the project plan, or terminate the project. This structured approach helps ensure that resources are allocated efficiently, risks are assessed at key points, and the project’s objectives are effectively met.

What is a Decision Review?

A Decision Review is a project management evaluation process conducted at the stage gates to assess the strategic decisions made during a project. It ensures that decisions are aligned with the project’s objectives, supported by relevant data, and contribute to its overall success. The review may lead to adjustments in the project plan, resource allocation, or a decision to continue, modify, or terminate the project.

What is a Milestone?

A milestone is a significant event or crucial point in a project’s timeline, indicating the completion of a substantial phase or achieving a specific objective. Milestones are typically used to measure progress and mark critical points throughout the project’s development.

See more on Lean Product Development

  Find out more about improving this business area

Get the latest news about Kaizen Institute